A Comparison of Reinforcement Learning and Deep Trajectory Based Stochastic Control Agents for Stepwise Mean-Variance Hedging

We consider two data-driven approaches to hedging, Reinforcement Learning and Deep Trajectory-based Stochastic Optimal Control, under a stepwise mean-variance objective. We compare their performance for a European call option in the presence of transaction costs under discrete trading schedules. We do this for a setting where stock prices follow Black-Scholes-Merton dynamics and the "book-keeping" price for the option is given by the Black-Scholes-Merton model with the same parameters. This simulated data setting provides a "sanitized" lab environment with simple enough features where we can conduct a detailed study of strengths, features, issues, and limitations of these two approaches. However, the formulation is model free and could allow any other setting with available book-keeping prices. We consider this study as a first step to develop, test, and validate autonomous hedging agents, and we provide blueprints for such efforts that address various concerns and requirements