On the contribution of modelling to multifunctional agriculture: learning from comparisons

In this paper a set of criteria is proposed for the evaluation of the potential contribution of modelling tools to strengthening the multifunctionality of agriculture. The four main areas of evaluation are (1) policy relevance, (2) the temporal resolution and scope, (3) the degree to which spatial and socio institutional scales and heterogeneity are addressed and (4) the level of integration in the assessment of scientific dimensions and of the multiple functions of agriculture. The evaluative criteria are applied to the portfolio of modelling approaches developed and applied in a joint project of the French research institute INRA and the Dutch Wageningen University & Research Centre. The CLUE-S model focuses on prediction of changes in multifunctional land-use at regional scale, given a set of predetermined scenarios or policy variants, e.g. for ex-ante policy assessment and initiation discussions on regional development. The two other modelling approaches are complementary and aim to address multifunctional farming activities. The Landscape IMAGES framework generates a range of static images of possible but sometimes distant futures for multifunctional farming activities in a small region or landscape. It supports the exploration of trade-offs between financial returns from agriculture, landscape quality, nature conservation and restoration, and environmental quality. Co-Viability Analysis generates viable trajectories of changes in farming activities within a given set of constraints, to reach a desired future. In the application implemented in the project, co-viability analysis focuses on grassland grazed by cattle which is also the breeding habitat of two wader species at field level. The three modelling approaches differ in their policy relevance, in the ways that spatial and socio institutional scales are addressed and in their levels of integration, but jointly cover most of the desired capabilities for assessment of multifunctionality. Caveats were particularly identified in the integration of the ...