The role of professional judgment in the application of United States accounting standards: An experimental study of the effect of professional judgment on financial reporting decisions of accountants.

This study examines two questions: (1) whether the level professional judgment required in the application of accounting standards affects the comparability of financial reporting; (2) whether financial statement preparers exploit the professional judgment in accounting standards in order to engage in earnings management. The study is motivated by former FASB Chair Dennis Beresford's call for simple accounting standards which rely heavily on the exercise of professional judgment and by SEC Chair Arthur Levitt's concerns that managers exploit the flexibility in accounting standards to engage in earnings management.