Understanding the effects of environment, social, and governance conduct on financial performance : arguments for a process and integrated modelling approach

To date, an overwhelming number of research findings on Environment, Social, and Governance (ESG) conduct and financial performance remains inconclusive. Furthermore, research has not identified nor explained the "underlying mechanisms" behind this relationship. To encourage future research, we discuss the mechanisms by identifying the first-order, mediating, and moderating variables. We synthesize recent studies for emerging themes and implications; argue for a process and integrated approach for modelling causality between ESG conduct and financial performance variables; and suggest methods to analyze the models. We also advocate for researchers to explore the idea that balancing corporate conduct among the E, S, and G components may provide revelations about financial performance. We also discuss how incorporating “greenwashing” in a process and integrated model may explain the ESG conduct and financial performance link, or more than likely the lack of it.