What is the right way to frame the competition policy baseline for assessing whether a new arrangement such as Google Book Settlement is pro-competitive?

The majority opinion makes no effort to explain how we as a society should confront this core one-sidedness of information. This is hardly just an antitrust problem. We will constantly confront information that is systematically more available to one side more than the other, and we will see...

We should want the ecosystem containing digital libraries to be rich and teeming. Randal Picker (Univ. of Chicago)