Can a Stock Index be Less Efficient than Underlying Shares? An Analysis Using Malta Stock Exchange Data.

Researchers often assume that stock market indices are the best possible yardstick in terms of market efficiency. The paper investigates this concept using data from the Malta Stock Exchange (MSE). The fact that a significant number of MSE shares do not trade everyday, may imply that the most liquid shares on this exchange are more efficient than the market index, whose value is dependent on shares of varying liquidity levels - including the less liquid ones. The paper applies various tests to compare the pricing efficiency of the MSE Index to that of the most liquid share quoted on the exchange. It is found that the MSE Index is still more efficient than the latter share.