Carbon Allowances and the Demand for Offsets : A Comprehensive Assessment of Imperfect Substitutes

The efficient use of market-based policy instruments is an area of increasing importance as scholars and policymakers work to balance effective climate policy with economic growth. Carbon allowances and carbon offsets, despite being statutorily substitutable, behave in practice like imperfect substitutes. This paper provides a synthesis of extant work, market data and the regulatory frameworks of the world's major carbon markets, and provides a comprehensive assessment of the drivers of demand for carbon offsets. This paper also provides a detailed assessment of the process through which international carbon offsets are produced, the UN's Clean Development Mechanism (CDM). Demand for carbon offsets is heavily influenced by key program design parameters specific to carbon market design and its implementation. These design parameters heavily influence the degree to which transaction costs, regulatory uncertainty and risk feature into the decisions of firms operating within the carbon trading program. This paper also identifies key extra-statutory drivers that are outside of the policymaker's control, which should be considered in both the policy design and implementation process. This paper provides an instructive set of guiding criteria for policymakers and scholars for the design of future market-based environmental policy