Optimality in nesting problems : New constraint programming models and a new global constraint for non-overlap

In two-dimensional nesting problems (irregular packing problems) small pieces with irregular shapes must be packed in large objects. A small number of exact methods have been proposed to solve nesting problems, typically focusing on a single problem variant, the strip packing problem. There are however several other variants of the nesting problem which were identified in the literature and are very relevant in the industry. In this paper, constraint programming (CP) is used to model and solve all the variants of irregular cutting and packing problems proposed in the literature. Three approaches, which differ in the representation of the variable domains, in the way they deal with the core constraints and in the objective functions, are the basis for the three models proposed for each variant of the problem. The non-overlap among pieces, which must be enforced for all the problem variants, is guaranteed through the new global constraint NoOverlap in one of the proposed approaches. Taking the benchmark instances for the strip-packing problem, new instances were generated for each problem variant. Extensive computational experiments were run with these problem instances from the literature to evaluate the performance of each approach applied to each problem variant. The models based on the global constraint NoOverlap performed consistently better for all variants due to the increased propagation and to the low memory usage. The performance of the CP model for the strip packing problem with the global constraint NoOverlap was then compared with the Dotted Board with Rotations using larger instances from the literature. The experiments show that the CP model with global constraint NoOverlap can quickly find good quality solutions in shorter computational times even for large instances.