State Dependent Asymmetric Loss and the Consensus Forecast of Real U.S. GDP Growth

It has been well documented that the consensus forecast from surveys of professional forecasters show a bias that varies over time. In this paper, we examine whether this bias may be due to forecasters having an asymmetric loss function. In contrast to previous research, we account for the time variation in the bias by making the loss function depend on the state of the economy. The asymmetry parameter in the loss function is specified to depend on set state variables which may cause forecasters to intentionally bias their forecasts. We consider both the Lin-Ex and asymmetric power loss functions. For the commonly used Lin-Ex and Lin-Lin loss functions, we show the model can be easily estimated by least squares. We apply our methodology to the consensus forecast of real U.S. GDP growth from the Survey of Professional Forecasters. We find that forecast uncertainty has an asymmetric effect on the asymmetry parameter in the loss function dependent upon whether the economy is in expansion or contraction. When the economy is in expansion, forecaster uncertainty is related to a negative bias in the median forecast of real GDP growth. In contrast, when the economy is in contraction, forecaster uncertainty is related to a positive bias in the median forecast of real GDP growth. Our results are robust to the particular loss function that is employed in the analysis.